What to Read While Waiting for Practical Magic 2: Witchy, Magical, and Romantic Reads

The countdown is on for Sept 18^th 2026! Practical Magic 2 is officially in the works, the follow-up film about sisterhood, loss, and witchcraft. We’re all hoping it captures the same bittersweet magic from the first film.

Fans of Alice Hoffman’s beloved Owens family are buzzing with excitement. This film is based on The Book of Magic so it should be great! If you’re like us, you can’t wait to dive back into a world of spellbinding sisters, family curses, and the power of love that defies even the darkest magic. While you wait for the movie release, why not sink into a few enchanting books that capture those same themes of witches, love, family, and the magic that binds it all together?

Here are 4 witchy reads to hold you over until Practical Magic 2 hits the big screen:

1. The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches by Sangu Mandanna
   If you adored the warmth and family ties in Practical Magic, this cozy fantasy is a must-read. Mika Moon is a witch who has always kept her powers hidden—until an unexpected invitation draws her into a found family that changes everything. With themes of belonging, love, and the courage to live authentically, this book is equal parts heartwarming and magical.
2. Witches of New York by Ami McKay
   If you adored the warmth and family ties in Practical Magic, this cozy fantasy is a must-read. Mika Moon is a witch who has always kept her powers hidden—until an unexpected invitation draws her into a found family that changes everything. With themes of belonging, love, and the courage to live authentically, this book is equal parts heartwarming and magical.
3. WishCraft by Savannah Kade (Indie Author Pick)
   This indie favorite blends witches, love, and destiny in an irresistible way. In WishCraft, magic is real but comes with rules—and a cost. Witch Delilah discovers that her powers may be failing on the one man she desperately needs them to work on. But the strange new occurrence may be tied to a love she never expected. With Hollywood glamour, simmering romance, and a dash of darkness, this book will enchant fans looking for something heartfelt and magical to dive into next.
4. Secret Society of Kings, Witches and Spirits by Farhana Uddin (Indie Author Pick)
   This indie favorite blends witches, love, and destiny in an irresistible way. In WishCraft, magic is real but comes with rules—and a cost. Witch Delilah discovers that her powers may be failing on the one man she desperately needs them to work on. But the strange new occurrence may be tied to a love she never expected. With Hollywood glamour, simmering romance, and a dash of darkness, this book will enchant fans looking for something heartfelt and magical to dive into next.

💫💫💫These indie picks tend to have a more intimate, quirky feel — ideal when you’re craving witchy romance that feels a bit more hidden and special.